There are so many negative comments on the Carnival Cruise and some other cruises but none on the Disney Magic. Is it that great?
Disney Magic Cruise was awsome. I was on it 2 years ago.
Everyone was very friendly, there was always something to do, and you dont wanna miss Castaway Cay. The first day we were at Castaway, later in the day it got a little cloudy and we saw a water funnel (or two). I was so cool. It seemed close, but it was far from the island and the ship. It didnt even touch ground (or in this case, water). Both days at Castaway, the weather was amazing. This was my first cruise so I don’t know about comparing to other cruises, but I can tell you, it was never a dull moment on the ship. This morning as I was leaving the ship for the last time on the trip, I was so sad to leave. It’s an amazing experience. Especially since at the Pirate party, there are fireworks (apparently Disney is the only cruise line allowed to do fireworks from out at sea, which makes it truely special and awsome) If you love Disney, then you will love this cruise. There is always something going on for anyone of any age.
I definitely recommend the Disney cruise!
If you want to share your experience, feel free to join our community http://www.ucruiser.com/ 
-Michael
I have never been on one, but would like to take my family! I would say it is amazing because the prices are higher then all the others you mentioned! I have done Royal Caribbean and loved it! I had nothing bad to say except it was a rough ride! Well worth it though!
References :
the disney cruises are definitely the best.
my best friend just got back form a disney magic cruise and she said it was a great cruise! disney is both classy and fun for all ages
carnival really isnt that bad though, the cruise line cant control the type of people that are on the boat
References :
I have never heard anything negative about Carnival. I have heard that Disney has an awful lot of kids on board, also the Travel Channel says that Disney is the only cruise line that has no casinos.
References :
Frequent cruiser
Disney Magic Cruise was awsome. I was on it 2 years ago.
Everyone was very friendly, there was always something to do, and you dont wanna miss Castaway Cay. The first day we were at Castaway, later in the day it got a little cloudy and we saw a water funnel (or two). I was so cool. It seemed close, but it was far from the island and the ship. It didnt even touch ground (or in this case, water). Both days at Castaway, the weather was amazing. This was my first cruise so I don’t know about comparing to other cruises, but I can tell you, it was never a dull moment on the ship. This morning as I was leaving the ship for the last time on the trip, I was so sad to leave. It’s an amazing experience. Especially since at the Pirate party, there are fireworks (apparently Disney is the only cruise line allowed to do fireworks from out at sea, which makes it truely special and awsome) If you love Disney, then you will love this cruise. There is always something going on for anyone of any age.
I definitely recommend the Disney cruise!
If you want to share your experience, feel free to join our community http://www.ucruiser.com/
-Michael
References :